Dorset, Fish & Seafood Restaurant Guide

2023 Review: This gorgeous old tavern on a corner site near the harbour – newly spiffed-up last autumn and with the recent addition of a conservatory – specialises in “excellent-quality” local seafood, served in a warm atmosphere that is “like being in France”.

“A real gem” – “hidden away above a real fishmonger on the historic Weymouth quayside” – this “inspired spot” serves “super-fresh fish, straight from the boat”, “brilliantly and creatively cooked” on a “superb tasting menu” that changes with the seasons and even the tides. Already a hit under former chef Mike Naidoo, regulars are hoping it will be “even better” under locally born chef-patron Ben Champkin, who arrived in early 2025 after working at L’Enclume in the Lake District and the Newt in Somerset (where he was head chef).

This legendary seafood shack at the Studland end of the Sandbanks chain ferry “does good things with amazing local fish”, “in a gorgeous harbour-side setting (ferry queues notwithstanding)” – with specialities including ultra-local Poole Bay oysters and a variety of whole fish cooked over fire for sharing.

“You are paying for the location” (especially the “beautiful view of Poole Bay”, if you pull off a table by the picture windows) at this tentacle of Rick Stein’s empire, but it’s nonetheless a “lovely” spot, where the service is “pleasant and attentive”, and the victuals – albeit a tad “formulaic” for some reporters – include “wonderful fishy tastes” that strengthened its ratings this year.

2022 Review: “Top-notch fish, chips and alternatives” plus a “lovely location” not far from the centre of town make this modern seaside café a good choice for breakfast or lunch, with stunning views from the terrace.

2024 Review: “Excellent fish, super-efficient service and a wonderful outlook on the beach” – three reasons to love this Jurassic Coast staple (est. 1991), and with siblings in West Bay and West Bexington; yes, the “seating is basic, but comfortable enough and with those views and the quality of the food, who cares?!” Top Tip – “look out for ‘Lobster Wednesday’! It’s the best deal on the coast!”.

A “lovely farm” in the Bride Valley (behind the Jurassic Coast) makes a “quirky setting for some well-executed Italian dishes” – best enjoyed in a “nice courtyard/patio area during the summer” when it’s “fun to watch the open kitchen at work”. It knocks out “good wood-fired pizza” among other dishes on the “well-priced menu”. The 300-acre Bredy farm brews its own cider and beer, has a campsite, and hosts three music festivals every year. Top Menu Tip – “standout tagliatelle with pork and fennel ragu”.